‘This may destroy all of it’: Packed council chambers, hours of opposition lead to deferral of Quinte West data centre decision

Some fought back tears, others challenged the project’s environmental and economic benefits, and dozens lined up to speak last week before Quinte West’s planning committee ultimately deferred a decision on a proposed data centre.
Council chambers were overflowing for the Sept. 17 Planning Advisory Committee meeting, as residents turned out in large numbers to oppose the proposed eight-megawatt facility at 7 Riverside Dr.
Over more than two hours of public comments, residents raised concerns about noise, flooding, chemical and fuel storage, electricity use and the potential impact on nearby homes and the environment.
By the end of the meeting, the committee opted to defer its decision, with members saying they needed more complete information before moving forward.
The committee convened to discuss a zoning-bylaw amendment that would permit the construction of the eight-megawatt “micro” data centre, as it has been dubbed by True North, the B.C.-based company that would build and operate the site.
The proposal would see an existing industrial building converted into a data centre that would use a closed-loop, waterless cooling system.
The rezoning would add an official data centre definition to the city’s zoning bylaw.
The advisory committee has recommended the site for approval due to its industrial suitability, but the rezoning would be an initial step and not a guarantee that the project would move forward to construction.
Awareness of and opposition to the proposed data centre had been growing since the statutory June 18 meeting of the Planning Advisory Committee, and grew steadily up to the Sept. 17 meeting, which saw the Quinte West council chambers fully packed, with overflow to the next room.
Sean Bouchard, a company official who was on-site to represent the rezoning application, presented a short video to council and residents about a similar data centre in Kamloops, B.C.
The video was meant to assuage residents’ worries about noise pollution, vibration and potential contamination of the nearby floodplain, among other concerns.
After the presentation, dozens of people lined up to tell Bouchard and council they were unhappy with the proposal. Many were visibly and audibly emotional while giving their comments, with some even fighting back tears as they voiced their concerns.
Noel Lelievre, who lives 800 metres from the proposed site, fought back a shake in his voice as he explained that his wife has a noise sensitivity and could be adversely affected by the site being so close by.
“We bought our house because it’s a quiet area,” he said. “It’s a great house. We love the community. This may destroy all of it. I want to live in this house for the next 60 years. I don’t want to have that down the road and suddenly, it ruins everything.”
Other residents questioned how it could be possible that the noise wouldn’t affect neurodivergent people or even pollinating wildlife such as bees.
Megan Doss questioned why there was a push for it now while the country is still in the process of regulating data centres.
“What’s the rush?” asked Doss. “Why do we need to do this right now? Can we not wait a little bit until things are more regulated?”
Bouchard argued that Canada needs to build data centres now to preserve Canadian data sovereignty from U.S. tech companies.
Residents weren’t buying this argument.
“Is there anything other than just it’s now a Canadian data broker selling our data to somebody else versus an American one getting at it first,” asked Brad Dalmquist.
“Because otherwise, I’m not seeing where the economic benefit actually comes from.”
Besides individual residents, Lower Trent Conservation, whose board of directors is appointed by the elected councils of the municipalities within the watershed region, said in June that it could not support the application based on information then available, as consistency with provincial natural-hazard policy had not been demonstrated.
In particular, the floodway had not been confirmed by an Ontario land surveyor.
Brian Keem of Jewel Engineering stated that, based on their modelling, the proposed development would be kept entirely out of the floodplain and he did not expect any problems acquiring the permit from Lower Trent Conservation.
Area resident James Reagan raised concerns about the fuel to run the site’s generators being stored next to the floodplain and the potential environmental consequences in the case of a spill or other incident.
Reagan claims that, based on his own research, the generators would require 57,000 litres of diesel fuel and violate provincial planning standards that prohibit storing hazardous materials and bulk fuels on a floodplain.
Bouchard rebutted Reagan, referring to studies conducted by Jewel Engineering that determined the site to be entirely off the floodplain.
Residents also raised a slew of other environmental concerns, ranging from the water usage of off-site power sources to run the centre’s closed-loop cooling system to the potential destructive ecological impacts of chemical leaks.
Bouchard confirmed that propylene glycol is used in the cooling system.
Hydro-rates going up because of the power draw from the project were also a concern mentioned several times.
True North claims on its website that ratepayers don’t foot the bill for their data centres.
Several residents in attendance went so far as to accuse members of the advisory committee of receiving kickbacks and bonuses in exchange for approval of the site, triggering a sharp rebuke from J.D. Brown, a non-elected public member of the committee.
“I’m a volunteer, a public member of this committee,” said Brown. “We have other public members on this committee as well. I make zero dollars. I don’t get kickbacks. I’ve never met these people in my life. I’m here to listen to you. I make nothing for it. So, I’d appreciate it if you wouldn’t level accusations that I’m getting something for this because I am not, not even for my time.”
Brown was backed up by chair Alyea, who explained to the assembled residents that there are several stages before a final decision is made by elected council.
After more than two hours had passed and several dozen residents had spoken against the proposal, the committee voted to defer the decision.
Committee member Maureen Simmons said members needed further and more complete information before a decision can be made.
